Slavery, Freedom, Public History, and National Identity: Charlottesville, Curaçao, Cartagena

Christina Proenza-Coles Connects African Diasporic Histories Across the Americas

In 2023, I had a couple of amazing experiences visiting Curaçao and Cartagena and learning from locals about African diaspora history, continually thinking, I wish my students were here too. I wanted to bring these spaces and these conversations back to Charlottesville. I was teaching a course called Afro-Caribbean-Latinx Histories that examined African descended people in the Caribbean and Latin America as protagonists in the development of the Americas. The people I met in Cartagena, a city on the Caribbean coast of Colombia, and Curaçao, an island off the coast of Venezuela, were preserving and publicly sharing histories that we had been studying and discussing at the University of Virginia, in the very sites where it had transpired.

This urgent feeling to share these conversations began when I met Dimitri Cloose at the office of Curaçao’s National Archeological Anthropological Memory Management, a government funded organization charged with “safeguarding our shared memory.” Dimitri described NAAM’s efforts to recognize the. histories and contributions of Afro-Curaçaoans, and he described recent controversies over how to tell a national story that acknowledged the centrality of slavery or downplayed it, what kinds of monuments should go up, and what kinds should come down. In effect, Curaçaoans were struggling with how to tell the story of a nation grounded in slavery and freedom. I told Dimitri that we were having the same conversations in Charlottesville about monuments and public memory, slavery and freedom, at that very moment. However, just as many of us are unfamiliar with the history of Curaçao, Dimitri was unaware of what was happening in Charlottesville, and we started an information exchange over email and eventually a working group, thanks to the Center for Cultural Landscapes at UVA’s School of Architecture, with collaborators from Curaçao, Charlottesville, and Cartagena to make a video about how these communities memorialize their complex histories in public spaces.

Charlottesville is ground zero in the United States’ founding contradiction of freedom and slavery, and now a leader in public history endeavors to reconcile this history with the future of American identity. Our video examines how sites in Charlottesville, like the University of Virginia, Monticello, the Jefferson School, and Court Square commemorate our shared history. Curaçao, formerly a Dutch colony, was an entrepot of the Atlantic slave trade as well as the site of two of the largest rebellions for freedom during the Age of Revolution, including a 1795 revolt led by an enslaved man named Tula. The plantation home where Tula initiated the island-wide uprising is now a museum that honors the enslaved Curaçaoans who lived, labored, and resisted there. Jeanne Henriquez, the curator of Museo Tula, takes us on a video tour of the site. Public monuments and public art in Curaçao’s capital, Willemstad, honor Tula as a national hero and founding father. Our video collaboration puts historic sites like Monticello and the Museo Tula, and memorialization efforts in Charlottesville’s Court Square and downtown Willemstad, into conversation, highlighting the differences and many similarities in our histories.

Cartagena is another deeply historic site in the history of the Americas, the entry point for many thousands of enslaved people and a place, like Charlottesville and Curaçao, that was built and developed by enslaved people and their descendants. Self-liberated Afro-Colombians founded the first free Black town in the Americas outside of Cartagena in the 1500s, San Basilio de Palenque. Palenque is now recognized by UNESCO as the oldest, continuous free Black town in the Americas, and it continues to thrive. Palenque native Erick Torres (top left) takes viewers on a video tour of his hometown, sharing details of its remarkable history. Wendy Sanchez (bottom left) takes us on a video tour of the city of Cartagena itself, highlighting the essential contributions of enslaved and free Afro-Colombians to the founding of the city and the nation.

I compiled the video tours of Cartagena, Curaçao, and Charlottesville into iMovie and added narrative and images from my lecture notes to offer a larger historical context and show how these histories interconnect (see below). I am grateful for the Charlottesville video shot by Leo Lesho (UVA Government and Economics ’26) and assistance from Josh Thorud and Drew MacQueen at UVA’s Media Center and Scholar’s Lab, respectively. The process of engaging with collaborators locally and internationally and the content we compiled was an incredibly productive experience. Wendy Sanchez and Erik Torres are professional guides whose tours I had taken. When the working group coalesced, we exchanged information and ideas over email, WhatsApp, and Instagram and the Colombian collaborators soon provided videos of the tours I had seen them give. Dimitri and I, on the other hand, traded scripts back and forth several times, each of us offering notes to the other about how something would read in our respective local and national contexts. I returned to Curaçao in 2024 to meet with Dimitri and Jeanne Henriquez at NAAM and map out our videos. The following day, Jeanne gave me a wonderful tour of the Museo Tula, and I took video of her on my iPhone just to have as notes for the videographer. From the start of our collaboration, Dimitri wanted to enlist a local professional videographer, Tico Vos.

Christina Proenza-Coles, lecturer, American Studies, UVA (left) Jeanne Henriquez, curator, Museo Tula (center), Dimitri Cloose, director, National Archeological Anthropological Memory Management (right), in Curacao.

When it was time for our collaboration to conclude, Dimitri emailed me to say that the videographer had produced a video that did not match to the format we had discussed. For one thing, it was in Papiamento and not English, which Jeanne and Dimitri and I had intended. However, in a nation where Dutch and English are taught in the public schools (these languages along with Spanish are often used in public), creating resources about Curaçao’s national history and culture in the national Creole language most widely used by its polylingual residents is essential. The language itself is an example of the resilience of Afro-Curaçaoans, and, as Tico Vos put it, the beating heartbeat of the culture. In fact, much of the work at NAAM includes producing work in Papiamento. One of the NAAM initiatives I wish we had been able to include in our video is the very recently launched, Kaminda Nos a Prosperá (Where We Thrived), a Curaçao Cultural Landscapes project led by local archaeologist, Amy Victorina. This project uses GIS to recognize Afro-Curaçaoan cultural heritage sites on a digital map intended to guide visitors to these historic places, including sites of resistance, punishment, gathering, celebration and burial.

The video made by Tico Vos, titled Alma di Kòrsou (the Soul of Curaçao) “is more than a mini-documentary—it is a heartfelt invitation to explore the powerful spirit that has shaped our island.” This video consists of historical reenactments, dance, cuisine, and interviews with Curaçaoan artists, musicians, and historians, including Dimitri Cloose. I hope that we will have the opportunity to add English subtitles for our Anglophone audience in the future. Both videos, Alma di Kòrsou and Slavery, Freedom, Public History & National Identity: Charlottesville, Curaçao, Cartagena, explore these locations as fundamentally Black spaces whose complicated histories help us to better appreciate and understand the communities we are today.

Dr. Christina Proenza-Coles is a lecturer in the American Studies Department at UVA. Her work was supported in part by the Center for Cultural Landscapes. Watch her compiled video tours below.

Intuit Mailchimp logo

© 2024 UVA Center for Cultural Landscapes